Justin may have been lying about not knowing about The Clubhouse
This image appears in the gallery:
These '13 Reasons Why' Season 3 Fan Theories Will Make You Question EVERYTHING

3. Justin may have been lying about not knowing about The Clubhouse
No matter which way you spin it, Justin being oblivious about The Clubhouse makes next to no sense. Is there a possibility that Justin actually knew more than he let on? A few theories suggest that he may have known about The Clubhouse and kept it quiet. Could this be a season 3 twist?